Evidence Pilot
Organize vs. reason

A reference manager organizes your sources. Evidence Pilot holds the argument to account.

A citation library answers “what did I read?” It does not answer “which source supports this claim, which studies conflict, what did we exclude and why, and who signed off on that decision?” Evidence Pilot is built for the second question — the whole-project reasoning that a bibliography cannot carry.

We compare the job, not the logo. This page uses the category; named comparisons are sourced where a named comparison is accurate.

Organizing a library

Reference managers are excellent at this, and most researchers should keep one.

  • Storing records with metadata
  • Formatting citations in a chosen style
  • Clipping sources from a browser
  • Sharing a group bibliography
  • Attaching PDFs and annotations

Reasoning across a project

This is the job Evidence Pilot exists for.

  • Keeping every claim tied to its source
  • Building an evidence matrix with study design and outcome
  • Recording include/exclude screening decisions
  • Scoring confidence per claim, not per paper
  • Preserving an audit trail of who reviewed what

Where a reference manager is the right tool

If the work is a literature collection — a reading list, a shared bibliography, a manuscript with formatted citations — a reference manager does the job well and Evidence Pilot does not try to replace it. Evidence Pilot has no interest in being your library of record. It imports from one.

Where a citation list stops

A bibliography records that a source exists. It does not record that a claim depends on that source, that a second source contradicts it, that a study was screened out for a stated reason, or that a reviewer flagged a claim as low confidence. In a systematic review, a rapid review, a policy brief, an investigation, or a dissertation defense, those are exactly the questions a reader asks. Evidence Pilot keeps the answers together.

Organize vs. reason, side by side

CapabilityReference managerEvidence Pilot
Store references with metadatayesyes
Format citations in a chosen styleyesyes (RIS export)
Capture a source while readingyesyes (web capture)
Detect duplicate references on importyesyes (import health)
Claim-to-source map across a whole project—yes
Evidence matrix with study design and outcome—yes
Screening queue with recorded include/exclude decisionspartialyes
Confidence band per claim—yes
Reviewer roles and reviewer notespartialyes
Audit trail of research decisions—yes
PRISMA-style flow and checklist export—yes

Cells describe the job each category is designed for. “Partial” means some tools in the category offer something adjacent, not that every tool does. Evidence Pilot does not claim to verify facts, replace professional advice, or approve publication.

Keep both. Use your reference manager for the library and the formatted bibliography. Import RIS or BibTeX into Evidence Pilot when a project needs a source trail that survives review. The two tools answer different questions, and nothing is gained by forcing one to do the other’s job.

Start with a source trail, not a bibliography

If you are running a systematic or rapid review, the first artifact is usually an evidence table. We publish a free PRISMA-style evidence table template and source reliability rubric — columns, example rows, and CSV downloads — so you can start the trail before you choose any tool.

Common questions

Does Evidence Pilot replace a reference manager?

No. A reference manager is the library: it stores records and formats citations. Evidence Pilot is where the argument is checked: it keeps each claim tied to the source that supports it, records screening decisions, and builds an evidence matrix. Most researchers keep both and import RIS or BibTeX into Evidence Pilot when a project needs a defensible source trail.

Can I import my existing reference library?

Yes. Evidence Pilot imports RIS, BibTeX, DOI-ready records, and common reference-manager exports, then runs a local import health check that shows duplicates, missing metadata, and provider-observation conflicts before you treat the records as evidence. Import QA is local; it does not claim live provider verification.

What does “reason across a project” mean in practice?

It means the tool can answer questions a citation list cannot: which claim does this source support, which sources conflict, which studies were included or excluded and why, how confident is each claim, and who reviewed the decision. Those answers live in the evidence matrix, the screening queue, and the audit trail rather than in a bibliography.